If you’ve been charged with DUI in Goodyear, Arizona, one of your first questions might be: “Am I entitled to a jury trial for a DUI?” The answer can be complex, and it’s important to understand your rights under Arizona law. At Arizona DUI Pros, we help clients across Maricopa County navigate the criminal justice system, especially when it comes to asserting their right to a jury trial for a DUI.
Our firm focuses exclusively on DUI defense. We are familiar with the Goodyear Municipal Court and the specific procedures involved when someone demands a jury trial for a DUI. If you or someone you love is facing a DUI charge, don’t leave your future to chance—contact Arizona DUI Pros today at (602) 922-3755.
Understanding Your Right to a Jury Trial for a DUI
Not all DUI cases in Arizona automatically qualify for a jury trial. The right to a jury trial for a DUI depends on the severity of the charge and the potential penalties. Arizona recognizes DUI as a criminal offense under ARS §28-1381, and while some DUIs are classified as misdemeanors, others rise to the level of felony offenses, which may increase your entitlement to a jury trial.
Under Arizona law, a jury trial for a DUI is typically available when the charge carries the possibility of jail time. For first-time misdemeanor DUIs in Goodyear, defendants can request a jury trial for a DUI, but it must be done correctly and in a timely manner. This right is rooted in the Sixth Amendment of the U.S. Constitution and supported by Arizona case law.
Many clients are surprised to learn that municipal courts, like Goodyear Municipal Court, often default to bench trials, meaning the judge alone decides the outcome. However, you can request a jury trial for a DUI—and this choice could significantly affect your defense strategy and the outcome of your case.
Goodyear’s Court System and DUI Charges
DUI offenses that occur within the Goodyear city limits are typically prosecuted in Goodyear Municipal Court, located at:
📍 Goodyear Municipal Court
14455 W. Van Buren Street, Suite B101
Goodyear, AZ 85338
When charged with a misdemeanor DUI under ARS §28-1381, your case will likely be handled here. Felony DUI cases are transferred to Maricopa County Superior Court. Either way, you are entitled to seek a jury trial for a DUI, and you must make that request within the timelines set by Arizona criminal procedure.
The court processes in Goodyear can be intimidating, especially for first-time offenders. That’s why contacting Arizona DUI Pros at (602) 922-3755 early in the process can help ensure you don’t miss the opportunity to request a jury trial for a DUI.
🧑⚖️ Jury Selection Process in a DUI Trial
What Is Voir Dire?
In any jury trial for a DUI, the process starts with voir dire—a French term meaning “to speak the truth.” This is where attorneys from both sides question a pool of potential jurors to uncover bias, life experiences, or opinions that may affect how they view your case.
If you’re charged with DUI in Goodyear and request a jury trial for a DUI, the goal of voir dire is to find a group of impartial people who can judge your case fairly, based only on the evidence presented in court.
Who Qualifies to Be on the Jury?
In Arizona misdemeanor DUI cases, such as those under ARS §28-1381, a jury usually consists of six people. These jurors are selected from the local Goodyear community. Both the prosecution and defense have a say in who makes the final cut.
During this phase, Arizona DUI Pros will be watching for red flags—such as:
-
Jurors with law enforcement backgrounds
-
Those with strong anti-alcohol beliefs
-
People who’ve had personal experiences with DUI
These individuals may not be ideal in a jury trial for a DUI, and we can challenge them for cause or use our peremptory strikes to remove them.
Why Jury Selection Matters
The makeup of your jury can strongly impact how your case unfolds. In a jury trial for a DUI, it’s not just about presenting evidence—it’s about how the jurors interpret that evidence. Jurors bring their own life experiences into the courtroom, even when they try to be objective.
For example, a juror who believes field sobriety tests are flawed may question the officer’s conclusions. That juror might be more open to reasonable doubt, which could lead to an acquittal.
How Arizona DUI Pros Handles Voir Dire
At Arizona DUI Pros, we approach jury selection as a strategy—not just a formality. We analyze body language, tone, and even answers to casual questions. Every jury trial for a DUI is different, and choosing the right jurors is often the key to a successful outcome.
We aim to find jurors who are skeptical of flawed DUI science, open to reasonable doubt, and willing to hold the state to its burden of proof.
If you’re heading into a jury trial for a DUI in Goodyear, don’t go in blind. Call Arizona DUI Pros at (602) 922-3755 for a personalized defense strategy.
Scenario 1: First-Time DUI in Goodyear – Requesting a Jury Trial
Hypothetical Scenario:
Jessica, a 27-year-old teacher, is pulled over on the I-10 after leaving a happy hour in Goodyear. She had two glasses of wine and believed she was okay to drive. After a traffic stop, she is arrested and charged with a first-time DUI under ARS §28-1381(A)(2) for having a BAC of 0.10%.
Jessica is understandably shaken. She’s never been in legal trouble before and assumes the case will be handled by a judge. During her arraignment at Goodyear Municipal Court, the judge informs her that her case is eligible for a jury trial for a DUI, but that she must file a formal request.
After consulting with Arizona DUI Pros, Jessica learns that the jury trial for a DUI must be requested early in the case, typically before the pre-trial conference. Our team quickly files the motion and begins preparing a defense that leverages the different dynamics of a jury trial compared to a bench trial.
By choosing a jury trial for a DUI, Jessica’s case benefits from our strategy of appealing to community standards, highlighting the lack of impairment despite the BAC reading. With thorough cross-examination of the arresting officer and DUI testing protocols, the jury finds her not guilty.
This scenario illustrates how even first-time offenders can benefit from asserting their right to a jury trial for a DUI—and why immediate legal representation is critical.
Scenario 2: Repeat Offense DUI – How the Right to a Jury Trial Applies
Hypothetical Scenario:
Greg, age 42, is stopped in Goodyear on suspicion of DUI. This is his second offense within five years, making it a Class 1 misdemeanor under ARS §28-1381(K). The maximum penalty includes up to six months in jail, which means he is absolutely entitled to a jury trial for a DUI.
Greg is concerned because his first conviction was a plea deal with no trial. This time, he doesn’t want to plead guilty again without fighting the charge. He contacts Arizona DUI Pros at (602) 922-3755 and schedules a free consultation.
Our team explains that not only is he entitled to a jury trial for a DUI, but it’s likely the better choice given the high potential penalties. We work with Greg to develop a defense involving inconsistencies in the field sobriety test and a flawed breathalyzer machine.
The trial begins in Goodyear Municipal Court, and our team strategically uses voir dire to select a favorable jury. Greg’s case is presented to six jurors, who must all agree on guilt to convict. In the end, one juror isn’t convinced beyond a reasonable doubt—resulting in a hung jury and eventually a dismissal of charges.
Greg’s case shows how asserting the right to a jury trial for a DUI can lead to better outcomes, especially when facing serious repeat charges.
How ARS §28-1381 Impacts Your Right to a Jury Trial for a DUI
Arizona Revised Statute §28-1381 outlines the state’s laws on driving under the influence. It defines DUI offenses, including impairment and BAC limits, and lists penalties based on the circumstances.
Here’s why ARS §28-1381 matters in the context of a jury trial for a DUI:
-
It establishes DUI as a criminal offense, not just a traffic violation.
-
Penalties include jail time, fines, and license suspension—all of which trigger constitutional rights.
-
Because jail time is a possibility, the U.S. Supreme Court and Arizona courts recognize the right to a jury trial for a DUI under the Sixth Amendment.
If you’re facing DUI charges in Goodyear, Arizona DUI Pros will evaluate whether your case qualifies for a jury trial for a DUI and help you file the appropriate legal motions to secure one.
👁️ How Jurors Perceive DUI Evidence in Arizona Trials
Not All Evidence Is Equal
When you’re facing a jury trial for a DUI, it’s important to understand that the evidence presented by the prosecution won’t always have the same impact on a jury as it might on a judge. Jurors view things through a human lens—what seems technical or routine to the court can appear questionable or even unreliable to an everyday person.
Breath Tests and BAC Readings
In most DUI cases, the prosecution will present your blood alcohol content (BAC) from a breath or blood test. But in a jury trial for a DUI, jurors may have concerns:
-
Was the machine calibrated properly?
-
Could the result be affected by diet or medications?
-
How accurate is a breath test anyway?
Jurors often bring skepticism to the table—especially if the BAC is just above the legal limit.
Officer Testimony Isn’t Always Convincing
The arresting officer’s observations are a big part of most DUI cases. They might claim you were slurring, stumbling, or smelled like alcohol. But in a jury trial for a DUI, these statements can be questioned:
-
Was the officer’s report consistent with the video?
-
Did they exaggerate or misinterpret your behavior?
-
Could nervousness or fatigue explain your actions?
Arizona DUI Pros will challenge officer credibility when necessary to create doubt.
Field Sobriety Tests and Juror Doubt
Tests like the one-leg stand or walk-and-turn might sound scientific—but jurors often realize they’re subjective. In a jury trial for a DUI, we highlight:
-
The poor conditions where the test was conducted
-
The officer’s lack of explanation
-
Any physical issues you may have had
Jurors are much more likely than a judge to see these tests as flawed or unfair.
How Arizona DUI Pros Shapes Juror Perception
Our team doesn’t just present the facts—we help shape how the jury sees those facts. In a jury trial for a DUI, the story we tell matters. We help jurors see you—not just your BAC. We raise questions that the state may prefer to gloss over.
If you’re looking at a jury trial for a DUI, make sure your attorney knows how to talk to jurors—not just talk at them. That’s what we do best. Reach out to Arizona DUI Pros at (602) 922-3755 to learn how we can help.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
Q: Can I still get a jury trial for a DUI if my BAC was under 0.08%?
A: Yes, under ARS §28-1381(A)(1), you can still be charged if you were impaired to the slightest degree—even below 0.08%. If the offense carries potential jail time, you can request a jury trial for a DUI.Q: How many people are on the jury for a DUI trial in Goodyear?
A: In misdemeanor cases, juries usually consist of six jurors. All must agree on the verdict in Arizona.Q: What happens if I don’t request a jury trial for a DUI in time?
A: If you miss the window, the judge will hear your case in a bench trial. That’s why early legal help from Arizona DUI Pros is essential.Q: Do all DUI cases go to jury trial automatically?
A: No, a jury trial for a DUI must be specifically requested—usually before pre-trial.
Arizona Revised Statutes Related to DUI Jury Trials
Here are the most relevant statutes:
-
ARS §28-1381 – Standard DUI statute (impairment and BAC-based).
-
ARS §28-1382 – Extreme DUI (BAC of 0.15% or higher).
-
ARS §28-1383 – Aggravated DUI (felony DUI with prior offenses or other factors).
Understanding how these laws affect your eligibility for a jury trial for a DUI is crucial to mounting a successful defense.
Conclusion: Talk to Arizona DUI Pros Today
If you’ve been arrested for DUI in Goodyear, you may be entitled to a jury trial for a DUI—but you must act quickly and strategically. Whether it’s your first offense or you have a prior record, the right legal team can help you navigate Goodyear’s legal system and assert your rights effectively.
At Arizona DUI Pros, we know how to leverage the power of a jury trial for a DUI to your advantage. Our attorneys have handled countless DUI cases throughout Arizona and have experience inside Goodyear Municipal Court. Don’t wait—reach out to us today at (602) 922-3755 for a free consultation and let us help you protect your record, your license, and your future.
